If you have been searching for a probiotic that is actually built for you, Craft and Flore will both come up — and both genuinely manufacture a custom blend rather than picking one off a shelf. The difference is who they are built for. Craft engineers blends modeled on elite-athlete microbiomes for performance and recovery. Flore builds a clinically-oriented formula from your own gut sequencing to address symptoms, diversity, and everyday gut health. Here is an honest, side-by-side comparison so you can choose the right fit.

Flore vs. Craft at a glance

Flore Craft Custom Probiotics
Personalization model Manufactured-to-specification — a formula produced from your data Manufactured custom blend — engineered to your profile
Primary focus Clinical and everyday gut health — symptoms, diversity, repair Athletic performance and recovery
Reference model Your own gut data vs. clinical outcomes across 40,000+ formulations Comparison to elite-athlete microbiome signatures
Test method Shotgun metagenomics (stool DNA), strain-level resolution, run by accredited CLIA/CAP labs Microbiome and profile analysis used to engineer the blend
Formula breadth Up to 68 curated strains + 40+ prebiotics, combined per person Custom multi-strain blend tuned to your profile
Format Capsules or powder Powder blend
Use your own lab data Yes — accepts sequencing from any professional lab Uses its own profiling process
Reformulates on retest Yes — iterative test → formulate → retest loop Adapts the blend as your profile evolves
Licensed-provider platform Yes — Flore Clinical Consumer / performance focused
Peer-reviewed clinical study Yes — pilot open-label study, mSystems (ASM, 2024); RCTs underway Third-party tested and WADA-compliant; no equivalent published clinical study listed

The core difference: built for health vs. built for performance

Craft and Flore agree on the most important idea in this category: a probiotic should be made for you, not picked for you. Where they diverge is the goal. Craft draws on elite-athlete microbiome signatures and engineers a blend aimed at performance, recovery, and athletic edge — third-party tested and WADA-compliant, which matters if you compete. Flore builds your formula from your own stool-DNA sequencing, benchmarked against clinical outcomes rather than an athlete reference set, and is designed for symptoms, diversity, post-antibiotic repair, and long-term gut health. If you are a competitive athlete optimizing for performance, Craft is purpose-built for you. If your priority is resolving gut issues or improving everyday health with a clinically-oriented, retested formula, Flore is the better fit.

Where Craft is strong

Craft is one of the few brands that genuinely manufactures a custom blend, and its athlete-signature framing is a real point of difference for performance-minded users. WADA compliance and third-party testing are meaningful for anyone subject to anti-doping rules. If athletic optimization is your main reason for taking a probiotic, Craft is a serious, focused option.

Where Flore goes further

  • Clinical evidence in the category. Flore is supported by a peer-reviewed pilot (open-label) study published in mSystems (American Society for Microbiology, 2024), with randomized controlled trials (Regular One, Bright One) now underway.
  • Your data, any lab. Flore accepts sequencing from any professional lab and does not lock you into a single proprietary test. The sequencing itself is performed by accredited CLIA/CAP labs — Flore turns that data into the formula.
  • Depth of formulation. Up to 68 curated strains plus 40+ prebiotics, combined per person, with more than 40,000 unique formulas produced to date across 23,447 sequenced microbiomes.
  • A closed loop. Flore retests and reformulates over time, so your formula is validated by whether your gut actually changes.
  • Provider option. For complex cases, Flore Clinical lets a licensed provider co-manage your plan.

The honest bottom line

Both Flore and Craft manufacture a real custom formula — this is not a "custom vs. catalog" story. It is a difference of purpose. Choose Craft if you are optimizing athletic performance and recovery and value WADA compliance. Choose Flore if you want a formula built from your own microbiome data for symptoms and everyday gut health, supported by a peer-reviewed pilot study, available as capsules or powder, and able to use sequencing from any accredited lab.

Frequently asked questions

Is Flore better than Craft Custom Probiotics?

They are built for different goals. Craft engineers custom blends modeled on elite-athlete microbiomes for performance and recovery. Flore manufactures a formula from your own stool-DNA sequencing for symptoms, diversity, and everyday gut health, and is supported by a peer-reviewed pilot (open-label) study in mSystems (ASM, 2024) with randomized controlled trials now underway. For clinical and everyday gut health, Flore is the stronger fit; for athletic optimization, Craft is purpose-built.

Do both Flore and Craft make a truly custom probiotic?

Yes. Unlike brands that only match you to a pre-made product from a catalog, both Flore and Craft actually manufacture a blend tailored to you. The difference is the reference data and the goal: Flore uses your own gut sequencing for health outcomes, while Craft benchmarks against elite-athlete microbiome signatures for performance.

Can I use my existing microbiome test with Flore?

Yes. Flore accepts sequencing data from any professional lab, including SunGenomics, ASU, and CosmosID. Flore does not run the lab test itself — that is performed by accredited CLIA/CAP labs — and Flore turns the data into your custom formula.

Which one has published clinical research?

Flore is supported by a peer-reviewed pilot (open-label) study published in mSystems (American Society for Microbiology) in 2024, with randomized controlled trials now underway. Craft states that its formulas are third-party tested and WADA-compliant; it does not list an equivalent published clinical study of its custom blends.

Build your Flore formula →